When to Ask
Give your letter writers at least 6–8 weeks of lead time; 3 months is better. Professors juggle dozens of letter requests in spring and summer. Asking late produces rushed, generic letters — and is the single most common reason for a weak letter.
For an MD application cycle that opens AMCAS in early May, plan to ask in February or March. For AADSAS, ask by March. For CASPA (opens late April), ask by February.
How to Ask (Script)
Ask in person if you can — at office hours or after class. If email is your only option, keep it short and respectful. A working template:
Dear Professor [Last Name],
I took your [course name] in [semester], and your class was one of the most formative parts of my undergraduate science training. I am applying to [medical / dental / PA] school this cycle, and I am writing to ask whether you would be willing to write me a strong letter of recommendation.
If you feel you can speak meaningfully to my academic abilities and would be comfortable writing a strong letter, I would be grateful. If you do not feel that way for any reason, I completely understand and would prefer to know now rather than have you feel obligated.
Thank you for your time. I can stop by office hours this week to discuss further if helpful.
Best, [Your name]
The "out" in the second paragraph is the most important part. It signals respect and protects you from a lukewarm yes.
What to Send the Writer
Once they agree, send a packet that makes their job easy:
- CV or resume (one page)
- Unofficial transcript
- Personal statement draft (if you have one — they can reference its themes)
- List of schools and deadlines (or note "AMCAS Letter Service, deadline rolling")
- Specific reminders: courses you took with them, approximate grades, projects you completed, and 2–3 qualities you would like them to highlight if natural
- FERPA waiver status: confirm you have waived your right to view the letter
How to Follow Up
Polite follow-up cadence:
- 2 weeks before deadline: Brief reminder email.
- 1 week before deadline: Slightly more direct reminder, offering to discuss any concerns.
- 2 days before deadline: Final friendly check-in. Offer to stop by office hours.
- If the deadline passes: Email immediately, ask whether they need any additional information, and offer to push back the school's deadline if possible.
Most missed deadlines are inbox-related, not personal. Stay polite, persistent, and professional. After the letter is submitted, send a thank-you note — and update them once you receive interviews and acceptances.
